Nutter Butter and Dogs: Is it healthy?

Don’t we all love munching on snacks? A bite here and a bite there all day long. We usually crave sweet snacks like cookies, and more often than not, your pet dog would follow you with pleading eyes. We don’t blame you if you feel tempted to feed some of those Nutter Butters to your dog, but can your dog eat Nutter Butters without any health concerns? Let’s find out!

Can dogs eat Nutter Butters?

No, dogs should avoid eating Nutter Butter. The snack is high in sugar and fat content. Even though Nutter Butters do not contain any toxic ingredients, they still may cause diarrhea, stomach upset, and vomiting in your pup.

We understand that a cookie every once in a while won’t hurt anyone but don’t we all strive for the healthiest options for our dogs?

What makes Nutter Butter bad for your dog?       

You might be wondering why Nutter Butter is not good for your dog since it loves to eat peanut butter. The answer lies in the ingredients of Nutter Butter and the process through which it is produced.

As a rule of thumb, anything processed is not good for your dog. Nutter Butter is made with a whole lot of ingredients that are overprocessed at commercial levels. They aren’t exactly healthy for humans either, but we can still tolerate the hazards.

Related Post:  Can Dogs Eat Oat Flour? Is It Healthy for Dogs?

Our dogs’ little digestive systems are significantly different from ours. While dogs can eat various human foods, vets recommend avoiding food with seasonings and sugar. Nutter Butter contains lots of sugars, saturated fats, and artificial trans fats. These ingredients are bound to mess with your dog’s gut health.

That being said, Nutter Butter is not toxic to your dog. It can only upset their stomach resulting in diarrhea, vomiting, and stomach aches. The ingredients mentioned above are difficult to digest and would take longer to excrete out. Chocolate, however, is dangerous for dogs. You must never feed chocolate-coated Nutter Butter to your dog, even by mistake.

What to do if your dog ate Nutter Butter?

So your dog has finally accomplished its mission of stealing some Nutter Butter from right under your nose, and you are devastated now. Fear not, fellow pet owner, Nutter Butters are not poisonous (the plain ones) to your dog. They are simply unhealthy.

If your dog ate a chocolate-coated Nutter Butter, rush to the vet immediately. Chocolate is toxic for dogs. If it was a plain Nutter Butter, just keep a close eye on your dog. Skip its next meal and give your pup loads of freshwater to promote digestion as Nutter Butters are a bit dry.

Make sure your dog isn’t choking on any Nutter Butter bits. If it does seem to choke or you hear a wheezing sound in its breathing, rush to the hospital before it gets too late. Any signs of a tummy ache or throwing up is your cue for giving the vet a call.

Healthy alternatives – Homemade peanut butter treats

Your dog cannot enjoy the deliciousness of Nutter Butter, but does it have to miss all the fun? Certainly not!

The good pet owner in you won’t let your furry friend be sad about anything. What can you do then? You can make a fresh batch of completely safe peanut butter treats, and here’s how you do it:

Related Post:  Is It Safe for Dogs to Eat Potato Chips Like Ruffles?


  • Whole flour – 1 cup
  • Creamy or chunky peanut butter – ½ cup
  • Water or chicken/beef stock – ¼ cup
  • Unsweetened applesauce or mashed banana – ¼ cup (optional)
  • Cookie-cutter


  1. Preheat the oven to 350°F.
  2. In a bowl, mix flour, peanut butter, and applesauce. You can add a mashed banana if you don’t have applesauce. Ensure that there is no sugar or xylitol present in the peanut butter.
  3. For additional flavor and nutrients, use stock to make a dough instead of water. Gradually add the liquid until a thick dough is formed.
  4. Roll the dough to about ¼ inches thick. Use a cookie cutter of any shape to cut out dog treats.
  5. Place the cookies on a baking tray and bake for about 18 minutes. The cookies should have a nice golden color.
  6. Let them cool and store in an air-tight container.

Related FAQs to butter and dogs!

Can dogs eat Nutter Butter wafers?

No, dogs should not eat Nutter Butter wafers. These wafers are high in sugar and fat, which is not healthy for dogs at all.

Can dogs eat peanut butter?

Many dogs love peanut butter. It is safe for dogs to consume peanut butter as long as there is no xylitol present in it. Xylitol is toxic for dogs.

Are peanut butter cookies harmful to dogs?

Dogs cannot eat human peanut butter cookies due to the ingredients. You should only feed your pup homemade peanut butter cookies created especially for it.

Can dogs eat shortbread cookies?

Dogs should avoid eating anything with sugar and butter. These ingredients are not toxic for dogs, but they aren’t healthy either.

Is almond butter safe for your dog?

Dogs can occasionally eat almond butter. But you should be careful about whether your dog can digest almonds or not.

Concluding our thoughts on whether dogs can eat Nutter Butters!

As much as we love to share our favorite snacks with our four-legged friends, not everything is healthy for them. Granted, their pleading puppy eyes are too hard to ignore, but we must stay alert because our pet’s good health must be our number 1 priority. Nutter Butter isn’t the best snack to feed your dog. Instead, make those delicious treats at home by yourself that your dog can enjoy!

Related Post:  Can Dogs Eat Meatballs? Are Meatballs Safe For Dogs?
Photo of author

Immad Amir

Immad has a black Labrador who is his first child. With no prior experience of how to take care of his pooch, Immad started researching about what dogs love to eat. This blog is a journal of all the research Immad has done regarding a pet's diet.
We use cookies in order to give you the best possible experience on our website. By continuing to use this site, you agree to our use of cookies.